What Are the Risks of Hiring the Wrong HR Person?
Hiring the wrong HR person can have significant and lasting consequences for your business. Human Resources is the backbone of a successful organisation, influencing everything from recruitment and employee engagement to company culture and legal compliance. Choosing the wrong HR professional can result in costly mistakes that impact productivity, staff retention, and business reputation.
At The HR Recruiters, we’re HR professionals who’ve been in the thick of it ourselves – leading teams, managing change, navigating boardrooms, and dealing with all the beautiful complexity that comes with building brilliant workplaces, so we’ve seen first-hand how important it is to get HR hiring right.
In this article, we explore the key risks of hiring the wrong HR person and how you can avoid them.
1. Poor Recruitment Decisions
One of the most immediate dangers of hiring the wrong HR professional is flawed hiring decisions. Your HR team is responsible for attracting and selecting top talent. A poor HR hire can result in ineffective recruitment strategies, leading to mismatched candidates, increased turnover, and rising recruitment costs.
SEO keywords: HR recruitment mistakes, poor hiring decisions, recruitment process issues
2. Damage to Company Culture
A great HR professional will strengthen and protect your company culture. The wrong person in this role can quickly damage team morale, fail to address workplace conflicts, or enforce inconsistent policies. This can lead to disengaged employees and a toxic work environment, making it harder to retain your best people.
SEO keywords: company culture, employee engagement, HR culture fit
3. Increased Legal and Compliance Risks
HR is responsible for ensuring your organisation complies with employment law, health and safety regulations, and internal policies. Hiring an underqualified or inexperienced HR professional can result in costly legal mistakes, tribunal claims, and damage to your brand reputation.
SEO keywords: HR compliance risks, employment law mistakes, legal HR issues
4. Wasted Time and Resources
The wrong HR hire costs more than just their salary. Poor HR management can lead to administrative errors, inefficient processes, and wasted resources on unnecessary or ineffective initiatives. You’ll also incur additional costs to re-hire and retrain if the hire doesn’t work out.
SEO keywords: cost of bad hire, HR recruitment costs, HR inefficiency
5. Negative Impact on Employee Retention
One of HR’s core functions is to enable leaders to support, develop, and retain your workforce. A disengaged or ineffective HR colleague can lead to low employee satisfaction, missed development opportunities, and increased staff turnover, all of which will affect your bottom line.
SEO keywords: employee retention, HR impact on retention, staff turnover
How to Avoid Hiring the Wrong HR Person
The best way to avoid these risks is by working with a specialist HR recruiter that understands your business needs and company culture. At The HR Recruiters, we use a proven recruitment process focused on a guaranteed culture-fit; we use in-depth culture and values assessment tools to ensure you find the right HR professional the first time.
Key HR recruitment tips:
Clearly define the HR role and required competencies
Assess culture fit alongside skills and experience
Use structured interviews and behavioural assessments to ensure objectivity
Partner with an expert HR recruiter
Final Thoughts
Hiring the right HR professional is a key investment in your company’s success. The wrong hire can set your business back months, cost thousands, and negatively impact your people. By partnering with experienced HR recruitment specialists, you can protect your business and build a thriving workplace.
If you’d like expert support with your next HR hire, contact The HR Recruiters today. We specialise in sourcing high-calibre HR professionals who will add long-term value to your organisation.
The HR Recruiters – where culture-fit comes guaranteed.
